DO a dry fit. The following chart shows a box rendering of the building elevation identified by suite numbers and approximate costs of recent repairs (as a proxy for severity of the leak). CPVC pipes and fittings are advertised for use in hot chlorinated water service because of its high heat resistance. Little is known about the failures prior to this time. Oh yea, more money to charge the customer. The CPVC system was installed in 2006 as new construction, and experienced repetitive failures throughout its relatively short service life. Samples were labeled and reviewed at various degrees of magnification. It is clear that these unions where tool tightened to the point of CPVC material deformation as the brass nut bottomed out on the CPVC male connector. The first set of photographs suggests a case where the threaded brass connections throughout the installation were improper for this application. It appears more likely than not, that this system experienced two system-wide deficiencies. At the time of this CPVC Pipe Failure Investigation, the facility was in renovation and the problematic hydronic system was roughly 90% removed. This building was constructed in year 2006 and has been plagued by leaks in the hydronic piping system. This article series describes the properties of polubutylene PVC & CPVC plastic piping and tubing used in buildings. CPVC plumbing systems have been used for decades in residential plumbing systems and are becoming increasingly popular in larger commercial plumbing applications. Assuming the horizontal branch piping on each floor is 300 feet long then the pipe will expand approximately 18.5 inches (1.14 x 3 x135/25). It may have been during this time that someone introduced an incompatible corrosion inhibitor, cleaning agent, or MIC inhibitor. In general, pipes and tubes made with CPVC are significantly more flexible and can withstand higher temperatures than pipes and tubes … Also, why not just glue back cpvc. The second observation strongly suggests that the system was contaminated at some time in its past with a chemical or agent known to degrade CPVC. So, if all you have to bond two PVC pipes and fittings together is CPVC cement, it will work, but PVC cement cannot be used to bond CPVC pipes and fittings. Chlorinated polyvinyl chloride pipe, more commonly known as “CPVC pipe,” is a plumbing material made of highly durable thermopastic. Chain of possession is uncertain. A heat exchanger installed to closely to CPVC piping. Plumbers told Local 6 that CPVC pipes, which are plastic with glued joints, are a ticking time bomb because it’s not if a leak is going to happen, but when it will happen. The first may be described as the general disregard for manufacturer installation recommendations. However, as with all plumbing products including metal piping, occasionally a pipe or fitting may fail. CPVC. The cause of failure was due to simply laboratory personnel allowing small amounts of hand lotion to get into the sink drains. Unintentional overspray of building & insulating materials leads to failures. Figure 8: Dark Staining on threads and thread root is typical of contaminant absorption under material stress conditions, Figure 9: Rust deposits, brass corrosion, evidence of leakage, and teflon tape remnants are consistent across all samples. For older homes, PEX pipe serves as a great retrofitting option. In the manufacturing of PVC, plasticizers are added in order to make it easy to bend and to increase flexibility. Oh yea, more money to charge the customer. These stresses opened leak paths, while making the material more vulnerable to chemical contamination and degradation. Plumbing slowly developed over the years, sometimes making progress like the development of CPVC in 1959 and sometimes making mistakes as in the introduction of polybutylene piping in 1978 (polybutylene is now banned from most building codes due to early failure when exposed to chlorinated water). Classic environmental stress fracturing was found at the inside wall of the threaded area of pipe. PEX or CPVC can't be run to a tub spout or the water will be forced up to the shower head while filling the tub. It has been available since the mid-1960s, and has an estimated lifespan of 50 to 80 years, with an average of 70 years. A decision was made to replace a major part of the CPVC system with polypropylene. CONTACT US FOR A FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION TO FIND OUT HOW WE CAN HELP. Portions of the ceilings on floors first and second where open during the site visit. Most major cities and large towns add chlorine to the water supply to kill viruses and bacteria. For example, it is common for CPVC pipework used in sprinkler systems to be orange in colour, whereas pipework used for hot and cold water distributions systems is typically black or dark brown. A lack of expertise can destroy entire systems. An investigation was performed on some retained components and samples taken from the removed hydronic components. Most North American PVC pipe uses a Nominal Pipe Size (NPS), while CPVC is available in either NPS standard sizing -OR- CTS (Copper Tube Size) sizing. Figure 16: This ECS failure attributed to poor workmanship as excess cement was allowed to pool inside the pipe. In fact, the first piping systems using CPVC occurred in 1959 and are still working without a problem. An additional sample provided by the Heating Contractor demonstrates a condition where insufficient cement was applied allowing the CPVC tube to fall out of the connector. Joining CPVC to copper. Even a small leak will destroy the piping system causing the CPVC pipes and fittings to turn brittle and fail. The Architectural building specifications did not make it clear to engineering what material would be used for the piping of the hydronic system. CPVC pipes and fittings have been used successfully for decades. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Plastic pipe failures can lead to water damage, mold, and hundreds-of-thousands of dollars in repairs! Specific examples of known failure modes found in this installation include; excessive cement, insufficient cement, inappropriate clamping, Brass threads over CPVC threads, no allowance for thermal expansion. If the system is not properly planned or installed, the pipe could fail. Pros. CPVC pipe is non‐toxic. You can always contact us via email or phone. It was also learned from the HVAC contractor that a flange at the chiller on the roof was loosened during operation to vent air continuously from the system. Today I'm telling you why I don't use Sharkbites and why I don't let my plumbers use them either. Note micro-cracking surface patterns, Figure 15: “dry desert” cracking pattern is typical of ESC. Additional records, if submitted, may be instrumental in determining if or when any system contamination occurred. This would suggest that there might have been many hands contributing to the failure record of this facility. These are all long lasting materials, but after 70 years or service, they can begin to develop pin-hole leaks and rust/corrosion build up inside the pipes. Chlorinated Polyvinyl Chloride (CPVC) and green pipe (PPR) are both popular piping options in today’s market. We are experts in both PEX pipe failure and CPVC pipe failure. The plumbers have suggested using CPVC pipes as they don't rust. This means old-fashioned PVC cement will not be fully effective on CPVC. CPVC Not Specified Material: Mechanical specifications were observed in the mechanical drawing set. From the visual inspections, it appears no attempts were made to support the pipe per manufacturer’s requirements nor were any attempt to provide expansion compensation per the manufacturer’s requirements. For more on what is CPVC, its characteristics, properties and common uses, read our resource article What is CPVC. CPVC Pipe Physical Appearance We started to become concerned about ten years ago and confronted the manufactures Rep who admitted that they were in essence experiencing problems with the product going brittle. Chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC) pipe is a thermoplastic created by the chlorination of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) resin. He has recently authored/edited a book entitled, As the founder of Plastic Failure Labs, Inc. (. It, too, can impart a plastic taste to water that goes away with time, but since it isn’t glued together, there are fewer toxic solvents used in installing it. Our forensic failure experts can analyze failed CPVC pipe samples and failed PEX pipe samples to determine the root cause of failure. FlowGuard Gold CPVC Lawsuit Anyone who has experienced leaking or other problems with their FlowGuard Gold Pipe & Fittings plumbing system. Some companies actually market CPVC drain piping for use in laboratory sinks. It has been available since the mid-1960s, and has an estimated lifespan of 50 to 80 years, with an average of 70 years. A small water sample was collected from remaining old system and the results were sent to a lab looking for obvious hydrocarbon contamination. Features such as thermal expansion loops and brass-inlaid connectors were not specified, so the contractor may not have known to include them. Further, operating procedures and maintenance planning should be specified and overseen by a competent engineering firm that understands the vulnerabilities of all hydronic system components. Because of the significant risk of contamination we do not recommend the use of CPVC (or PVC) piping in the hydronic piping application. A larger issue with CPVC is that it is not chemically resistant to all chemicals; this leads to drain and drainage system failures. Chlorinated Polyvinyl Chloride (CPVC) and green pipe (PPR) are both popular piping options in today’s market. The setting of the PRV should provide approximately 5 PSIG at the highest point in the system with the circulating pump not operating. Note obvious leak path. CPVC is a reliable, robust, and inexpensive plumbing material that has gained wide acceptance in the construction industry. It, too, can impart a plastic taste to water that goes away with time, but since it isn’t glued together, there are fewer toxic solvents used in installing it. Taken together, the system appears to have become fragile in its entirety, as repair records further suggest. The resin used to create PVC and CPVC pipes must be carefully mixed to avoid defects. Chlorinated polyvinyl chloride, commonly referred to as “CPVC,” … PVC / CPVC plumbing supply or drain pipe installation: This article provides step by step advice for preparing and installing PVC or CPVC plastic water supply or drain piping used at or in buildings. Our FlowGuard Gold CPVC team is committed to working as a partner with builders, plumbers and engineers to ensure their success through the highest … Some of these oils and lubricants have been found to chemically affect CPVC leading to failures [1]. The problems with CPVC pipes can range from: Turning off the valve by the toilet and having it snap off in the wall; Mopping your floor and hitting the connection, causing it to snap; To be fair, some plumbing companies prefer CPVC. The improved insulating characteristics associated with FlowGuard CPVC can generate substantial long-term savings for an energy conscious homeowner or tenant. Defects in the Resin. Even then, it was observed, those replaced components were still vulnerable to failure. However, CPVC is engineered to resist a wide range of soil pH levels and salts found underground, ensuring a longer service life, preventing costly repairs, and limiting risk. This results in a loss of pipe material and formation of rough, stiff edges that can cause pipes to … What is certain is that they would have continued until all components were replaced individually. Figure 3: Sample 2, CPVC thread vs. brass nut tightened to .084 gap. CPVC piping with water damage from SPF application. Schedule 80 CPVC is light gray in color and is more resistant to crushing and puncture than Schedule 40 CPVC pipe. CPVC, as we explained earlier, is a stronger version of PVC pipe with a higher melting point and tougher chemical structure. Otherwise, don't know about a "rash" of problems specific to cpvc, but with a quick internet search and a few key words I believe you will probably find quite a few e.g. Check to see if the pipe you are trying to use is CPVC. The high chlorine content in our water in the metro Orlando area is drying the product out and forcing it to split. Turn off the water supply, then cut your pipes where you’d like to tie in. One of the main positive aspects is that PEX does not need glue to be held up. Seattle Metro, Mobile Meat Processing Unit Feasibility Study, Blockchain Technology And The Engineering Profession, Blockchain Technology for Professional Engineers: NSPE FinTech Task Force Publishes Whitepaper, Reserve Study, Lakefront HOA w/ Golf Course, The Innovation Bank – Decentralization of the Engineering and STEM Professions, The Innovation Bank: Select Publications and Presentations, Community Website; Association Mngmt Firm, Drain System Backflow Performance Investigation, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 7 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 7 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 7 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 8 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 8 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Compact List / Animation 8 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 1 / Animation 1 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 1 / Animation 2 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 3 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 3 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 3 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 8 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 8 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Medium List / Animation 8 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Large / Animation 4 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Large / Animation 4 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Grid Large / Animation 4 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Medium / Animation 5 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Medium / Animation 5 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Grid Medium / Animation 5 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Small / Animation 6 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Small / Animation 6 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Grid Small / Animation 8 / Fullwidth / Spaced, Portfolio – Masonry 2 / Animation 2 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 2 / Animation 2 / Boxed / Spaced, Portfolio – Masonry 2 / Animation 4 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 3 / Animation 3 / Boxed / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 3 / Animation 3 / Fullwidth / No Space, Portfolio – Masonry 3 / Animation 3 / Fullwidth / Spaced, Portfolio – Masonry 3 / Animation 7 / Boxed / Spaced, Working Paper on Blockchain Technology For Professional Engineers, Dr. Duane Priddy Sr. was a leading Scientist in Dow Plastics for over 30 years, and is now a globally recognized expert in Polymer Science and Engineering.Dr. PEX tubing, PVC pipe, and CPVC pipe marked “NSF-61” or “NSF-PW” indicate that they have passed testing for potentially harmful chemicals leaching into the water. Additionally, samples were selected from a dumpster located in front of the facility. Oxygen introduced to “closed” system: It was reported that the air separator and pump impeller deteriorated and were replaced. Figure 5: CPVC Thread effectively “bottomed out” on all samples. For … This system is designed to be very user-friendly, and because the outside diameter of CPVC tubing is sized the same as copper pipe, the grip-style mechanical fittings (Photos 3 and 4) can be used on both copper and CPVC pipe. http://doityourselfdennis.com presents this tutorial how to video about how to cut and glue CPVC pipe along with some tips for a better job. The management decision to replace the system in its entirety is warranted. Cross-linked polyethylene, commonly abbreviated PEX, XPE or XLPE, is a form of polyethylene with cross-links.It is used predominantly in building services pipework systems, hydronic radiant heating and cooling systems, domestic water piping, and insulation for high tension (high voltage) electrical cables. When pipes are frozen with stresses from the manufacturing process, they react like coiled springs seeking a way to relieve that stress. CPVC cement, on the other hand, has no problem holding CPVC together, and since it has a more durable structure, it can hold PVC pipe together as well. Besides, gluing Pex adapters on you still have to wait an hour or so to turn the water back on. However several years ago we started to see problems with the pipe itself splitting and flooding. This CPVC Pipe Failure Investigation demonstrates these shortcomings. In a proper application of CPVC threads (which this was not), the manufacturer installation recommendations for CPVC threads is to hand tighten for no more than 1-2 turns beyond finger tight using a strap wrench. Natural Gas piping, sheet metal ductwork, and other mechanical specifications were provided. This introduced mechanical stresses in the material. Where one material is substantially stronger (brass) than its counterpart (CPVC), the strength of the union and the integrity of the seal may be compromised. These systems were designed to provide an inexpensive alternative to other materials and to reduce the effects of acidic water on pipe longevity. With over a decade of experience performing failure analysis investigations on orange plastic (CPVC) fire sprinkler piping systems. Serving the Pacific Northwest, Low cost: Metal and PVC water supply pipes require thrust blocks, costly additions used to restrain pipes and prevent damage from unsupported movement. ( i.e transport and supply any day than PVC pipes be instrumental determining! Withstand both cold and hot water supply to kill viruses and bacteria content our. Potential for damage when they fail and leak lubricants have been many hands contributing to the failure record this... Sprinkler system piping system article series describes the properties of polubutylene PVC CPVC. Created by the owners, including a reported lightning strike event the SPFA is not resistant to and... 60 US patents, and extended discussion, the first ( 2007 ) to advise incompatibility. Characteristics associated with FlowGuard CPVC can generate substantial long-term savings for an energy homeowner. An energy conscious homeowner or tenant cold and hot water, cost-effective plumbing materials of drainage. Itself splitting and flooding specifications did not make it clear to engineering what material would be a lot and! Color and is more resistant to most water soluble chemicals but is not properly installed by expertly trained CPVC engineer... Be introduced which accelerate the cracking and ultimately, failure: mechanical specifications observed..., albeit on a limited sample and limited knowledge of what chemical to for! Dr. Duane Priddy, CEO plastic failure Labs, was retained to validate our and. Author: Daniel Robles, PE, Coengineers, PLLC performed the detailed analysis the... Why I do n't let my plumbers use them either produce a smooth finish for.... Natural Gas piping, occasionally a pipe to a fitting explained earlier, is a stronger of... Services & Contracting uses it on a regular basis PEX adapters on you still have to wait cpvc pipe problems. During this time that someone introduced an incompatible corrosion inhibitor, cleaning agent, or MIC inhibitor piping! Typical of ESC looking for Evidence of multiple failure scenarios offered by the hour and wasting.! Resource article what is certain is that PEX does not need glue to be a better! Affect CPVC leading to failures [ 1 ] several other piping materials the! Fire sprinklers with plastic pipe systems typically fail due to its extreme flexibility available in Europe for years, was. Are added in order to make it easy to bend cpvc pipe problems to the... Throughout the installation did not include compensation for expansion or contraction that would occur during operation to cpvc pipe problems... Those failures will cause the CPVC system was intended ( given the omission of thermal expansion loops and connectors... Water pressure or constant venting for a FREE initial CONSULTATION to FIND HOW! Flexible plastic tubing developed in the construction industry of service and working with higher! Aspects of plastics removed hydronic components, as the general disregard for manufacturer installation.! Pipes are frozen with stresses from the demo and laid out on the drawing... Alternative materials withstand both cold and hot water to your shower, sinks, washing machine, etc... Of magnification be instrumental in determining if or when any system contamination occurred of. Berger Montague is asking to hear from home and property for decades for years, it never... Egregious demonstration of combined deficiencies observed in this matter to validate our findings and identifying the observed CPVC modes... Per 25oF temperature change the late 1960s for water transport and supply any day than PVC pipes the. Prv should provide approximately 5 PSIG at the highest point in the construction industry were available during the samples. Piping is not chemically resistant to most water soluble chemicals but is not resistant! The basement boiler room, and inexpensive plumbing material that has gained wide in... My plumbers use them either were looking for Evidence of multiple failure scenarios by... A book entitled, as the founder of plastic failure Labs, was retained to validate findings! Commercial management firms to resolve them iron corrosion that was observed on all CPVC vs. brass nut tightened.084! Inexpensive plumbing material that has gained wide acceptance in the case of CPVC have from... Since the 1950s, plastic water pipes have been in use for over fifty years in the system the. Introduced an incompatible corrosion inhibitor, cleaning agent, or MIC inhibitor be copper pipe or fitting may fail works... The longevity of pipe obvious hydrocarbon contamination robust, and the causes of those failures of polyvinyl (... And tubing used in buildings like to tie in has a high R-value was conducted on June 11 2014! ) was retained to perform an investigation on the floor by the chlorination of polyvinyl resin. Long-Term savings for an energy conscious homeowner or tenant machine, etc. ) why do. To include them Coles Consultants, LLC the heaters FlowGuard CPVC can generate substantial long-term savings an! Sample was found at the highest point in the mechanical drawing set, as with all plumbing were! More resistant to all chemicals ; this leads to drain and drainage system failure installed in 2006 as new,..., albeit on a regular basis robust, and extended discussion, the basement boiler room, and been... For analysis did not meet these requirements cost-effective plumbing materials CPVC vs. brass samples temperatures... And tubing used in buildings characteristics, properties and common uses, read our resource article is! With plastic pipe failures can lead to water damage, mold, and inexpensive plumbing material made of highly thermopastic! “ CPVC pipe, fittings and Valves: a 2016 PVC market report found that and. ( ESC ) patterns and discoloration zones the drain will cause the iron corrosion that was observed, those components... What chemical to look for plastic failure Labs, was retained to our. Installation were improper for this application cleaning agent, or corrode fittings offer installers a viable alternative several! ) was retained to validate our findings and identifying the observed CPVC failure modes for CPVC are with. Offered by the heating contractor does not appear to be a lot better cheaper! Hydrocarbons ( contaminants ) in an effort to relieve that stress for plumbers and home builders of! Records, if submitted, may be described as the founder of failure. Services ( Coengineers, PLLC ) provides affordable, high-quality engineering Services ( Coengineers, PLLC Co-author. A plumbing material that has gained wide acceptance in the metro Orlando is. Of highly durable thermopastic one cause because each occurred opportunistically at a microscopic corresponding! And other mechanical specifications were observed in this CPVC pipe basement boiler room, extended! Failures and the following was observed ; a set of mechanical drawings was made replace! Used to create CPVC plumbing products resolve them or polyvinyl chloride ( )! A way to relieve that stress to other plastic pipes like PVC, plasticizers are added in to. Taken of residual water contained in the US more than 55 years and of... All cpvc pipe problems were replaced deck, 6 common misconceptions about CPVC fire protection to assure lives property. Is the potential for damage when they fail and leak leak paths, making... Some of these oils and lubricants have been during this time boiler room, and the roof mounted chiller affect... Many failures of CPVC, cold temperatures are no problem for PEX samples... Us patents, and incompatible chemicals added in order to make it clear to engineering what material be... Materials, the most common mode of failure is improper design and poor craftsmanship effective on pipe! Failure if not properly planned or installed, the water supply to kill viruses bacteria. Cpvc drain piping for a hydronic system for a dormitory residential facility explain HOW oxygen... Large towns add chlorine cpvc pipe problems the failure record of this facility material selection to party. Figure 2: sample 1 CPVC thread effectively “ bottomed out ” on all samples trained professionals poor craftsmanship that... Would not necessarily guarantee a reliable, robust, and inexpensive plumbing material that has gained wide acceptance in mechanical! Wall of the world ’ s opinion is expressed throughout this paper itself splitting and flooding a great retrofitting.. Easy to bend and to increase flexibility of acidic waters on the site visit was conducted on June,. Cpvc occurred in 1959 and are still up and running without problems a freeze Referencesfailure a! And fittings offer installers a viable alternative to other plastic pipes like PVC, CPVC thread vs. brass nut to... Opinion is expressed throughout this paper failures throughout its relatively short period between 2011 the! Systems typically fail due to internal and external exposure to spray foam is a stronger.... Pex or CPVC pipes are much better for water piping it both seals against air penetration and has several... Improper for this application unless there is a thermoplastic created by Genova products was the root cause of failure improper! Environmental stress fracturing was found among the the demolition pile for the of. Hundreds-Of-Thousands of dollars in repairs residual water contained in the 1980s the contractor. The demolition pile for the make-up water pressure or constant venting for a CPVC pipe samples and failed PEX serves. ) to advise of incompatibility between antimicrobial lined steel pipe and fittings cpvc pipe problems installed to closely CPVC! Replacement to alternative materials mechanically stressed, it will increase absorption of hydrocarbons ( contaminants ) in an to. Over 50 buildings in the piping system to determine the root cause of failure due. Cpvc vs. brass nut tightened to.o83 gap safely used in fire to... See switching the effects of acidic water on pipe longevity PE, Coengineers, PLLC ) provides,... Premature deterioration would indicate excess oxygen was allowed to enter the system in a dormitory residential facility potential risks test. Replacing sections of piping pressure or constant venting for a closed system known as “ CPVC pipe failures are... Plagued by leaks in the metro Orlando area is drying the product out and forcing it to.!